Header Artificial Selection vs Natural Selection

What started this adventure of comparing Artificial and Natural Selection was derived from watching this video on dogs, basically mutts vs pure breeds. The video is called, The Bizarre Truth About Purebreed Dogs (and Why Mutts Are Better) by the comedian Adam Conover in Adam Ruins Everything. Please note this should be for high school students or older. Please watch and enjoy the video which should lead you to the next sections on natural and artificial selection.

TruTV Logo link to site for Videos and Copyright
Adam Ruins Everything is licensed under Turner Entertainment Networks, Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.

Image of Ecological, Sexual, and Artificial Selection Link to Berkeley.edu Natural Selection -Charles Darwin's Theory Link to topic of Ecological Selection by Revolvy Link to Sexual Selection from evolution.berkeley.edu Link to Artificial Selection-Wikipedia Genetic Diversity

What is Natural Section?

There are four conditions according to Charles Darwin of natural selection that need to occur:

  1. There is variation in traits in members of the same species.
  2. Populations of species are capable of producing more offspring that the environment can support.
  3. Traits can be inherited and passed from parents to offspring.
  4. Due to environmental resource factors, many offspring won’t survive. The more advantageous a trait, the more the probability of their survival increases.
The two main selections in Darwin’s Theory are ecological selection and sexual selection.

In Darwin’s influential book written in 1859, On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle of Life, he describes natural selection animals and plants with considerably desirable traits are favored for reproduction. This is analogous to what artificial selection or selective breeding is, except the traits are not derived by competition to reproduce or ecological factors.

What is Ecological Selection?

Ecological selection is referred to as environmental selection minus the sexual selection. In other words, inheritance of specific traits are driven by ecological factors not sexual competition.

What is Sexual Selection?

Sexual selection according to Darwin is traits selected according to their role in mating and is different from ecological factors. Sexual selection occurs in two ways by contests by the same sex for access to the opposite sex or by choice. For instance, horns, antlers, and other combative devices are from sexual selection because they are directly involved in helping the individual obtain a mate. Choice involves competition for attention from the opposite sex. For example, the tail of a peacock is to attract females; it is a selected trait that is not used to attack or defend.

What is Artificial Selection?

Artificial selection or selective breeding is a process where humans consciously select organisms for or against particular traits. These desirable traits are not always ones that help the species to be able to utilize their resources to survive. For example, choosing cattle with beneficial features such as larger in size or producing more milk. Or, for instance, a dog for his size or coloring, i.e. the Doberman.

The Problem with Artificial Selection

The problems that can arise with Artificial Selection can be exemplified with the Doberman. The Doberman is breed for appearance. This genetic makeup also has a defected gene that causes narcolepsy, a condition that causes dogs to uncontrollably fall asleep, in its chromosomic structure.
Moreover, genetic diversity plays an important role in the adaptability to survive. Variation in the gene pool allows diversity and the ability to adapt. Evolution is based on genetic diversity. With little genetic diversity with a species, reproduction, vulnerability to diseases and other issues result when inbreeding occurs.

Back To Top   Back to Project Page

The learning audience is for high school students and older.